Yield-Starved Foreign Investors Are Flooding the U.S. Muni Market

Author: Frank Holmes
Date Posted: May 18, 2016 Read time: 3 min

Strange are the times when a third of all government debt around the world carries a negative yield, and yet such is the case today

Stampede! American Munis are attracting foreign investment, validating their Safe Haven status

Strange are the times when a third of all government debt around the world carries a negative yield, and yet such is the case today. From Japan to eurozone countries, investors are faced with the tough decision of accepting subzero yields, doing nothing—or seeking other so-called “safe haven” options. Many have rediscovered gold, and as I pointed out earlier this week, demand for the yellow metal as an investment just had its best first quarter ever, with near-record inflows into gold ETFs.

Gold ETF Holdings Have Jumped 25% Since January
click to enlarge

But gold hasn’t been the only beneficiary.

Overseas investors, starved for yield, are also flocking to investment-grade U.S. municipal bonds, which help fund infrastructure projects at the state and local levels. (Seventy-five percent of all infrastructure spending in the U.S., in fact, is financed with municipal bonds.) Munis offer a history of low volatility and near-zero default rates, not to mention diversification and attractive yields in a world of little to no yield. Below, notice that Japan’s 10-year government bond yield continues to edge lower into negative territory.

Low-Yielding Government Debt Pushing Foreign Investors into U.S. muni bonds
click to enlarge

Unlike U.S. citizens, foreign investors are ineligible to take advantage of munis’ income tax-exempt feature. Nevertheless, they’re piling into the $3.7 trillion muni market, validating the “safe haven” status many investors assign to munis. By the end of 2015, foreign investors held more than $85 billion in American municipal debt, up from $72 billion in 2010.

Foreign Investment in U.S. Muni Bonds Surges on Negative INterest Rates
click to enlarge

As of the end of April, nearly $10 trillion worth of government bonds across the globe bore a negative yield. As this amount climbs, inflows into high-quality, short-term munis are expected to accelerate.

Muni bond funds are already seeing a sustained run of weekly inflows that began in October, with a massive $1.2 billion entering the market in the week ended May 11, following $709.7 million the previous week. This includes both American mutual funds and ETFs, so domestic and foreign investors are reflected here.

31 consecutive weeks of Municipal bond fund inflows
click to enlarge

One of my favorite investing proverbs is “Follow the money,” and in the case of short-term munis, it’s important to recognize that a global surge in demand is taking place as central banks continue to lower rates and debase their nations’ currencies. Municipal bonds, as well as gold, have traditionally satisfied investors’ need for a store of value when other options seem too volatile or risky. Today, the unfavorable monetary climate abroad makes American munis all the more attractive.


All opinions expressed and data provided are subject to change without notice. Some of these opinions may not be appropriate to every investor.

Holdings may change daily. Holdings are reported as of the most recent quarter-end. None of the securities mentioned in the article were held by any accounts managed by U.S. Global Investors as of 3/31/2016.