Australia May Be the Saving Grace for the Rare Earth Metals Market
When Colorado-based Molycorp Inc. filed for bankruptcy in 2015, the U.S. lost its sole remaining miner and producer of rare earth elements (REEs)--those inconspicuous metals with unpronounceable names like praseodymium, yttrium and gadolinium.
When Colorado-based Molycorp Inc. filed for bankruptcy in 2015, the U.S. lost its sole remaining miner and producer of rare earth elements (REEs)—those inconspicuous metals with unpronounceable names like praseodymium, yttrium and gadolinium.
The company’s key project, the open-pit Mountain Pass mine in California, was once the world’s top source for rare earths, which are used today in a growing number of important high-tech applications, from lasers to wind turbines to missile guidance systems.
Multinationals as varied as Boeing, Honeywell, Sherwin-Williams, Bayer, ExxonMobil, Stanley Black & Decker and Qualcomm all have financial interests in the availability of REEs. The iPhone in your pocket would be inoperable without 16 of the 17 rare earth metals. Each F-35 fighter jet is estimated to contain about half a ton of the elements. To improve motor efficiency, Tesla’s 2019 Model S and Model X are installed with a permanent magnet motor that uses rare earth neodymium-iron-boron magnets.
Lacking its own domestic supplier, the U.S. has for years been dependent on China, the world’s biggest producer by a huge margin. The Asian country has enjoyed a near-monopoly in the rare earth market, representing between 80 percent and 90 percent of global output.
Cracks in that market dominance are beginning to appear, however, as Australia has recently emerged as a competitive supplier. From 2013 to 2018, Australia’s annual output of REEs exploded more than 1,600 percent, from around 1,000 tonnes to 19,000 tonnes, according to consultancy firm Roskill.
The largest Australian company involved in the mining and processing of REEs is Lynas Corp., which trades on the Australian Securities Exchange (ASX). Other rare earth mining companies trade there as well, including Northern Minerals Ltd., Arafura Resources Ltd. and Alkane Resources Ltd., but Lynas is the biggest player by far, not just in Australia but in the entire world outside of China. It controls the prolific Mt. Weld deposit in Western Australia, which is responsible for about 8 percent of world output. Once ore is extracted, the company processes it in Malaysia at the Lynas Advanced Materials Plant.
I’ll have more to say on Lynas in a moment.
Seeking to Diversify Away From China
As I discussed back in May, China’s dominance poses a considerable economic and national security risk to the U.S., one that’s become all the more apparent in the months since trade relations between Beijing and Washington turned sour. “Control of the rare earth supply gives Beijing both economic and military advantages over the U.S.,” writes Michael Silver, CEO of American Elements, in a Wall Street Journal op-ed.
The word “weaponized” is overused today, but that’s precisely what Chinese officials have done with respect to these vital elements, threatening to curb their export to the U.S. in retaliation over tariffs.
As if to validate these not-so-veiled threats, China’s rare earth exports to the U.S. have begun to slow. In September, they fell nearly 18 percent from the previous month.
There’s a precedent of China using REEs as geopolitical leverage. In 2010, Beijing blocked their export to Japan in a dispute over the detention of a Chinese fishing captain. The move ultimately failed, as it had the effect of forcing Japan to build up its own rare earth supply chain. The Japanese government, in fact, helped fund the development of Lynas. Just last year, Japanese researchers discovered what’s been described as a “semi-infinite” deposit of rare earth metals underneath the country’s waters.
Faced with a similar predicament, the U.S. government and American corporations have been considering ways to limit their reliance on foreign supply. In December 2017, President Donald Trump issued an executive order calling on government agencies to explore strategies to “reduce the Nation’s reliance on critical materials.” Among the strategies—locating domestic deposits, improving access to data and expediting mining permits.
More recently, Trump met with Canadian Prime Minister Justin Trudeau to discuss ways to “develop a joint action plan on critical minerals collaboration.”
On the corporate side, Apple announced in September that it would stop using mined REEs in a key component of the iPhone. Instead it plans to use only recycled metals.
I should point out that extracting these elements is expensive and chemically complex, and costs can run prohibitively high when mining activity follows environmental regulations. Processing them can create large amounts of pollution, sometimes even yielding radioactive waste. (Lynas’ processing plant in Malaysia is no stranger to controversy for this very reason.) This is part of the reason why the U.S. was willing to allow the task to be outsourced to other countries, including China, which now has control of asset prices.
All of this is to stress the difficulties involved in rebuilding an entire supply chain from scratch.
“There are reasons [new] developments have been slow to get off the ground,” explains Australian economic analyst David Uren. “There is no open market pricing for rare earth elements; they are negotiated in private, so there is no futures market to give comfort to investors. To the extent one can tell what price they are being traded at, they have been very cheap for a decade with markets depressed by illegal Chinese product smuggled out of the country.”
Lynas—the World’s Greatest Hope?
For manufacturers and other companies with a financial interest in REEs that wish to diversify away from Chinese suppliers, Australia’s Lynas appears to the best option. Investors recognized this as well, pushing Lynas stock to an all-time high in late May. Shares have since receded somewhat, but I believe there’s still plenty of upside potential.
Again, Lynas is the largest miner and processor of rare earths outside of China, with the possible capacity to meet approximately a third of global demand for REEs such as praseodymium and neodymium, according to Stratfor.
To meet this demand, Lynas is expanding its processing capacity by partnering with chemical manufacturer Blue Line Corp., based in San Antonio, Texas—home to U.S. Global Investors, coincidentally enough. Together, the two companies are set to build a rare earth processing and separation plant in Hondo, Texas, a little more than 40 miles west of San Antonio. The facility could open as soon as 2023.
Blue Line CEO Jon Blumenthal expresses the need for companies to become less dependent on Chinese-produced REEs.
“Without rare earths, you can’t have a car today,” he says. “Probably not many people are going to know what lanthanum is, but they do know what gasoline is. You need a catalyst in order to make gasoline and a catalyst has a coating of lanthanum on it.”
I would keep my eye on Lynas stock the closer we get to the 2023 opening of the Texas plant, especially if there’s any escalation in trade tensions between the U.S. and China.
All opinions expressed and data provided are subject to change without notice. Some of these opinions may not be appropriate to every investor. By clicking the link(s) above, you will be directed to a third-party website(s). U.S. Global Investors does not endorse all information supplied by this/these website(s) and is not responsible for its/their content.
Holdings may change daily. Holdings are reported as of the most recent quarter-end. The following securities mentioned in the article were held by one or more accounts managed by U.S. Global Investors as of 9/30/2019: The Boeing Co.,